User talk:David MacQuigg/Sandbox/ThorCon nuclear reactor: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(add critique from) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== IAEA as a reliable source == | == IAEA as a reliable source == | ||
'''From | '''From Wikipedia editors:'''<br> | ||
Submission declined on 13 March 2022 by Mako001<br> | |||
The IAEA source seems to be just a report that ThorCon themselves have written, so it doesn't make it any better. | |||
This is a terrible article. | This is a terrible article. | ||
''' | '''Responses:'''<br> | ||
"The IAEA review was originally drafted by me, according to the outline and rules that they laid down. IAEA people reviewed, edited, critiqued it repeatedly until it was published, by them." - Robert Hargraves, 11 March 2022. | "The IAEA review was originally drafted by me, according to the outline and rules that they laid down. IAEA people reviewed, edited, critiqued it repeatedly until it was published, by them." - Robert Hargraves, Founder of ThorCon, 11 March 2022. | ||
"There were dozens of interactions between IAEA editors and me. The tables of tech specs were required by IAEA and filled in by me and checked by others. There can be no more accurate source." Robert Hargraves, Founder of ThorCon, 15 March 2022. | |||
Revision as of 07:54, 30 April 2022
IAEA as a reliable source
From Wikipedia editors:
Submission declined on 13 March 2022 by Mako001
The IAEA source seems to be just a report that ThorCon themselves have written, so it doesn't make it any better.
This is a terrible article.
Responses:
"The IAEA review was originally drafted by me, according to the outline and rules that they laid down. IAEA people reviewed, edited, critiqued it repeatedly until it was published, by them." - Robert Hargraves, Founder of ThorCon, 11 March 2022.
"There were dozens of interactions between IAEA editors and me. The tables of tech specs were required by IAEA and filled in by me and checked by others. There can be no more accurate source." Robert Hargraves, Founder of ThorCon, 15 March 2022.