Talk:Eugenics: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Anthony Argyriou
No edit summary
imported>Russell Potter
(comments)
Line 4: Line 4:


As Nancy points out, eugenics is still embodied in government policy, in Singapore and China. [[User:Anthony Argyriou|Anthony Argyriou]] 19:40, 1 June 2007 (CDT)
As Nancy points out, eugenics is still embodied in government policy, in Singapore and China. [[User:Anthony Argyriou|Anthony Argyriou]] 19:40, 1 June 2007 (CDT)
:I'd just say, as I would with any CZ entry, that if there is more to be told, go ahead and tell it!  I don't think that the article in its current form is all that U.S.-centric -- if there is more to be said about other countries, let's add it (though perhaps nationality ''per se'' may not be the best organizing principle, if there's strong evidence for Eugenics as an ''international'' phenomenon).
:The ideas in the bulleted list are not meant to be a list of common beliefs, just examples of ''some'' of the beliefs of different followers of this idea (the idea of more children diluting 'moral force', interestingly enough, was espoused by [[Thomas Edison]]!
:And again, if eugenicist ideas are still embodied in law (I know some of the U.S. laws were never removed from the books) in some places, let's mention and document that.  I'll tweak the tense so as to set the stage for such materials. [[User:Russell Potter|Russell Potter]] 20:15, 1 June 2007 (CDT)

Revision as of 20:15, 1 June 2007

Eugenics still exists, it is not a past tense thing. Nancy Sculerati 18:43, 1 June 2007 (CDT)

This article is worded in a very U.S.-centric way, while eugenics laws were passed in Britain, Germany, and Scandinavia as well as the U.S. and Canada. Also, some eugenicists, including Margaret Sanger, encouraged "superior" people to have more children, contrary to the statement in the article That families with more children dispersed and diluted the "moral force" of each offspring. "More children from the fit, less from the unfit-that is the chief issue of birth control," according to Sanger.

As Nancy points out, eugenics is still embodied in government policy, in Singapore and China. Anthony Argyriou 19:40, 1 June 2007 (CDT)

I'd just say, as I would with any CZ entry, that if there is more to be told, go ahead and tell it! I don't think that the article in its current form is all that U.S.-centric -- if there is more to be said about other countries, let's add it (though perhaps nationality per se may not be the best organizing principle, if there's strong evidence for Eugenics as an international phenomenon).
The ideas in the bulleted list are not meant to be a list of common beliefs, just examples of some of the beliefs of different followers of this idea (the idea of more children diluting 'moral force', interestingly enough, was espoused by Thomas Edison!
And again, if eugenicist ideas are still embodied in law (I know some of the U.S. laws were never removed from the books) in some places, let's mention and document that. I'll tweak the tense so as to set the stage for such materials. Russell Potter 20:15, 1 June 2007 (CDT)