Afghanistan War (2001-2021): Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
Line 73: Line 73:
Afghan Taliban fighters surrendered at Kunduz, but foreign fighters, including [[Namangami#Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan|Juma Namangami]], a leader of the [[Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan]], fought on. Namangami led the al-Qaeda force at Kunduz, and was killed in a U.S. airstrike; the overall Taliban commander was Mohammed Fazal.  <ref>Berntsen, p. 242</ref>  
Afghan Taliban fighters surrendered at Kunduz, but foreign fighters, including [[Namangami#Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan|Juma Namangami]], a leader of the [[Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan]], fought on. Namangami led the al-Qaeda force at Kunduz, and was killed in a U.S. airstrike; the overall Taliban commander was Mohammed Fazal.  <ref>Berntsen, p. 242</ref>  


Kunduz fell on November 23-24. The Northern Alliance was not prepared to handle a large number of prisoners, some died on the way to prison in [[Sheberghan]] and [[Qala-i-Jangi]]. There have been allegations that some prisoners were deliberately killed by being locked into shipping containers, and others may have been roughly interrogated by U.S. forces.
Kunduz fell on November 23-24. 8,000 Taliban surrendered at  Kunduz in late November. Amir Jhan, apparently accepted as a negotiator by both sides, said that after the surrender, he counted only 3,015.  There are many theories for prisoner deaths, ranging from compounded errors to deliberate killing; there appear to have been miscalculations on all sides.
<ref>{{citation
| title = Were U.S. troops in Afghanistan complicit in a massacre?
| journal = Salon.com
| author = Michelle Goldberg
| url = http://dir.salon.com/story/news/feature/2002/06/15/massacre/print.html
}}</ref> The Northern Alliance was not prepared to handle a large number of prisoners. One of the most basic errors was failing to search all prisoners. 
 
some died on the way to prison in [[Sheberghan]] and [[Qala-i-Jangi]].  
 
There have been allegations that some prisoners were deliberately killed by being locked into shipping containers, and others may have been roughly interrogated by U.S. forces.
 
The fighting appears to have started when the Qali-i-Jangi guards began tying up the prisoners. They had managed to secure 250 of the 400 detainees. The remaining prisoners - suspecting they were about to be executed - then revolted. Guardian (U.K.) correspondent Luke Harding wrote "Their fears were unwarranted: the Americans had taken pains to school General Abdul Rashid Dostam, the castle's owner, and his fellow opposition commanders that the Taliban prisoners should be treated according to international law." <ref name=Guardian2001-11-27>{{citation
| title = Allies direct the death rites of trapped Taliban fighters
| author = Luke Harding
| journal = Guardian (U.K.) | date = November 27, 2001
| url = http://www.guardian.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,4308159,00.html}}</ref>


On November 25, prisoners at Qala-i Jangi prison killed guards by suicide attack with hidden grenades; they were forced into cells in the basement.<ref name=CNN2002-07-04>{{citation
On November 25, prisoners at Qala-i Jangi prison killed guards by suicide attack with hidden grenades; they were forced into cells in the basement.<ref name=CNN2002-07-04>{{citation
Line 80: Line 96:
  | journal = CNN
  | journal = CNN
  | url = http://archives.cnn.com/2001/WORLD/asiapcf/central/12/20/ret.walker.transcript/
  | url = http://archives.cnn.com/2001/WORLD/asiapcf/central/12/20/ret.walker.transcript/
  | author = Robert Pelton}}</ref> CIA personnel the next day, started interogating prisoners. An American who volunteered for the Taliban, [[John Walker Lindh]], was not yet identified. The prisoners turned on their guards; CIA officer Mike Spann was killed.<ref>Berntsen, pp. 250-253</ref> Dostum forced the last resisters out of the basement on November 30, when Lindh was identified.  
  | author = Robert Pelton}}</ref> CIA personnel the next day, started interogating prisoners. An American who volunteered for the Taliban, [[John Walker Lindh]], was not yet identified. The prisoners turned on their guards; CIA officer Mike Spann was killed.<ref>Berntsen, pp. 250-253</ref>  
 
Dostum forced the last resisters out of the basement on November 30, when Lindh was identified.  


CNN reporter Robert Pelton interviewed the hospitalized Lindh on December 2. Lindh explained he belonged to a Taliban auxiliary called ''Ansar'', or "helpers", which was divided by native language of the volunteers. He said bin Laden was in charge of the Arabic-speaking part. <ref name=CNN2002-07-04 />
CNN reporter Robert Pelton interviewed the hospitalized Lindh on December 2. Lindh explained he belonged to a Taliban auxiliary called ''Ansar'', or "helpers", which was divided by native language of the volunteers. He said bin Laden was in charge of the Arabic-speaking part. <ref name=CNN2002-07-04 />
Tora Bora is  an extremely rugged area south of Jalalabad as having two valleys running north and south.  
Tora Bora is  an extremely rugged area south of Jalalabad as having two valleys running north and south.
 
=====Tora Bora=====
=====Tora Bora=====
In the South, Pakistani forces are providing assistance on the routes out of Afghanistan into Pakistan. Opposition forces are moving north and south from Jalalabad forming "a hammer and an anvil," Franks said.  
In the South, Pakistani forces are providing assistance on the routes out of Afghanistan into Pakistan. Opposition forces are moving north and south from Jalalabad forming "a hammer and an anvil," Franks said.  

Revision as of 21:46, 13 May 2009

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

Template:TOC-right After the 9-11 attacks, the United States learned that the al-Qaeda senior leadership, who took responsibility for the attacks, were based in Afghanistan. The ruling Taliban refused to surrender that leadership and shut down their facilities, and the U.S., also invoking the NATO treaty of collective defense, issued a conditional ultimatum that if the demands were not met, a new Afghanistan War would begin in 2001.

NATO participation was the first invocation of Article 5, the collective defense agreement at the heart of the NATO Charter. The operation was also authorized by the United Nations Security Council Resolution 1373.[1]

Initial concept and its development

GEN Tommy Franks, commanding CENTCOM, set out a four-phase plan that was briefed to the President on September 21, 2001:[2]

  • Phase I: Set conditions and build forces to provide the National Command Authority credible military options: build alliances and prepare the battlefield
  • Phase II: Conduct initial combat operations and continue to set conditions for follow-on operations; begin initial humanitarian operations
  • Phase III: Conduct decisive combat operations in Afghanistan, continue to build coalition, and conduct operations
  • Phase IV: Establish capability of coalition partners to prevent the re-emergence of terrorism and establish support for humanitarian operation: expected to be a 3-5 year effort

It is a maxim of warfare that no plan survives contact with the enemy; it is a reality of modern warfare that no plan survives contact with higher headquarters. This particular set of plans also was quite different than others the U.S. had fought, in several aspects. It was to be a coalition from the start, both with the Afghan Northern Alliance against the Taliban government, with formal NATO cooperation and with both direct combat and assistive roles from other countries. Within the U.S. military, it was conceived as truly joint, not Army, Navy, Air Force, or Marine; Special Operations forces were also to have a major role.

On the 20th, Franks had a tense meeting with the Joint Chiefs of Staff (JCS), whom he felt each argued for a plan featuring their service. He asked for and received confirmation from the Secretary of Defense (SECDEF), Donald Rumsfeld, that he had full command authority to develop a service-independent approach.

The actual briefing to the President and Vice President was made by Franks, retiring Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff (CJCS) GEN Hugh Shelton, Vice CJCS GEN Dick Myers (who succeeded the retiring Shelton), and JSOC commander MG Dell Dailey; Dailey indicated the importance of special operations to the plan.

Phase I

Afghanistan is landlocked. Before any operations could proceed, basing rights needed to be established. Kyrgyzstan, which had had Special Forces trainers since 1999, allowed the initial basing at Dushanbe, which subsequently moved to a major facility at Manas. [3]

Airstrikes and special operations force insertions needed to be done on relatively moonless night, to avoid making them visible to air defenses. October 6 and 7 were optimal from the standpoint of lunar light. [4]

Before United States Army Special Forces teams could be attached to the various Northern Alliance forces, Central Intelligence Agency Special Activities Division officers needed to link with their leaders. At first, only one CIA unit, code named JAWBREAKER, was present, with the forces of Mohammed Fahim Khan, who had taken command of the Tajiks after al-Qaeda assassinated Ahmad Shah Massoud on September 9.

The Special Forces teams, under COL John Mulholland, waited at the K-2 base in Uzbekistan; for political reasons, Uzbekistan announced that it was assisting in humanitarian assistance and combat search and rescue. Air operations were controlled from Prince Sultan Air Base in Saudi Arabia. AC-130 gunships and other fixed-wing support aircraft flew from Qatar.

Phase II

Large-scale overt air attacks started on October 7, 2001. The public name was , Operation ENDURING FREEDOM.

It took approximately 2 weeks before the first Special Forces team, Operational Detachment A (ODA) 595 joined General Dostum of the Northern Alliance. Just afterwards, two direct action operations took place. [5] The first was a paratroop attack, by the 75th Ranger Regiment, to seize an airstrip coded Rhino. A second force, by a JSOC Special Mission Unit (SMU), was to attack the Kandahar headquarters of Mullah Omar. Rhino was to receive the first conventional ground combat unit, of U.S. Marines. [6]

Phase III

On October 30, GEN Franks met with Mohammed Fahim Khan and Gary Berntsen of the CIA. Franks set out his priorities: have the Northern Alliance forces of Dostum take the major Northern city of Mazar-e-Sarif, use it as a staging area to make a joint attack with Uzbek forces, now nder Berryelah Khan, to make a joint attack on Taloquan. Taking those cities would open an overland supply route to Uzbekistan. According to Bertsen, Franks wanted Fahim's forces, farther south on the Shomali Plains, to move west and cut off the escape of the Taliban in the north. Fahim argued that he wanted to move to take Kabul first. Bertsen saw Fahim's argument as poliitical; Franks restated his plan of Mazar-e-Sharif, Taloquan, and the Shomali Plains.[7]

Franks also described the northern cities as priorities, after which the The Northern Alliance would then move to take Bagram Air Base, and then go from the Panshjir Valley to the Shomali Plains north of Kabul. He did not state Fahim's argument for Kabul as strongly as did Bertnsen. Fahim agreed not to enter Kabul without Franks' permission; Franks and the CIA supported Hamid Karzai, a Durrani Pashtun as the interim national leader, and did not want tribal conflict between Pashtuns and the Northern Alliance tribes.[8] A day or two later, Berntsen and a Special Forces team talked to Fahim's forces on the Shomali Plains, and told them they could not have more airstrikes that were needed in the north.

Northern regional campaign

The attack on Mazir-e-Sharif began on November 5; it was captured on November 10. The battle was a series of probes, by Northern Alliance horse cavalry until Taliban resistance was met, and then the Special Forces team called in air strikes. Cavalry charges immediately following airstrikes, if a mix of the centuries, were effective.

Taloqan soon followed, as did Herat and Shindand in the east. [9]

The Northern Alliance told the U.S. team, on the 10th, that Taliban were retreating into Konduz, taking human shields. As Berntsen put it, "when an Afghan who has been in combat half his life and has witnessed scores of atrocities tells you something is going to be bad, you listen." Cutting off the linkup became a high priority. [10] Taliban leaders in Mazir-e-Sharif had negotiated a surrender of Konduz, with amnesty for Afghan Taliban but not for foreign fighters. [11]

Kabul

British Special Boat Service personnel joined U.S. special operators to seize Bagram Air Base outside Kabul on November 11.

Other ODAs linked up, and the Northern Alliance advanced, taking control of Kabul on November 13. Heavy fighting, however, continued. Konduz continued to resist, as did Kandahar.

Pursuing the Taliban

Kandahar fell and Taliban moved, variously south to Tora Bora and north to the Kunduz area.

Kunduz

Afghan Taliban fighters surrendered at Kunduz, but foreign fighters, including Juma Namangami, a leader of the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan, fought on. Namangami led the al-Qaeda force at Kunduz, and was killed in a U.S. airstrike; the overall Taliban commander was Mohammed Fazal. [12]

Kunduz fell on November 23-24. 8,000 Taliban surrendered at Kunduz in late November. Amir Jhan, apparently accepted as a negotiator by both sides, said that after the surrender, he counted only 3,015. There are many theories for prisoner deaths, ranging from compounded errors to deliberate killing; there appear to have been miscalculations on all sides. [13] The Northern Alliance was not prepared to handle a large number of prisoners. One of the most basic errors was failing to search all prisoners.

some died on the way to prison in Sheberghan and Qala-i-Jangi.

There have been allegations that some prisoners were deliberately killed by being locked into shipping containers, and others may have been roughly interrogated by U.S. forces.

The fighting appears to have started when the Qali-i-Jangi guards began tying up the prisoners. They had managed to secure 250 of the 400 detainees. The remaining prisoners - suspecting they were about to be executed - then revolted. Guardian (U.K.) correspondent Luke Harding wrote "Their fears were unwarranted: the Americans had taken pains to school General Abdul Rashid Dostam, the castle's owner, and his fellow opposition commanders that the Taliban prisoners should be treated according to international law." [14]

On November 25, prisoners at Qala-i Jangi prison killed guards by suicide attack with hidden grenades; they were forced into cells in the basement.[15] CIA personnel the next day, started interogating prisoners. An American who volunteered for the Taliban, John Walker Lindh, was not yet identified. The prisoners turned on their guards; CIA officer Mike Spann was killed.[16]

Dostum forced the last resisters out of the basement on November 30, when Lindh was identified.

CNN reporter Robert Pelton interviewed the hospitalized Lindh on December 2. Lindh explained he belonged to a Taliban auxiliary called Ansar, or "helpers", which was divided by native language of the volunteers. He said bin Laden was in charge of the Arabic-speaking part. [15] Tora Bora is an extremely rugged area south of Jalalabad as having two valleys running north and south.

Tora Bora

In the South, Pakistani forces are providing assistance on the routes out of Afghanistan into Pakistan. Opposition forces are moving north and south from Jalalabad forming "a hammer and an anvil," Franks said.

Change in American priorities

On November 27, Rumsfeld asked Franks for more detail on his Iraq planning. [17]

The U.S. set up Combined Joint Task Force 180 (CJTF-180) in June 2002 as the CENTCOM forward headquarters, under a lieutenant general.

Current situation

See also: Taliban
See also: International Security Assistance Force

There is an Afghan government in place, with military capability of its own, the Afghan National Army (ANA) as well as Police.

The war has taken on an international character, with much spillover into Pakistan, where there is an active Taliban insurgency. There is also sanctuary and spillover in Tajikistan and Uzbekistan, with complex diplomacy involving basing rights for Western forces versus Russian interests. Iran certainly is affected, both from Afghanistan directly and from insurgents crossing from the Pakistani province of Balochistan.

The major combat capability remains with the NATO International Security Assistance Force, commanded by a U.S. four-star general who is also commander of United States Forces - Afghanistan (USFOR-A).

Afghan security forces

Afghan National Army

The Afghan National Army is comprised of five corps, the 201st Corps based in Kabul; 203rd Corps in Gardez; 205th Corps in Kandahar; 207th Corps in Herat and the 209th Corps in Mazar-e-Sharif. Attached to each corps is an Afghan Regional Security Integration Command (ARSIC). Each ARSIC is comprised of a Regional Police Advisory Command (RPAC) and a Regional Corps Advisory Command (RCAC). The RPAC is responsible for training, coaching and mentoring all organizations of the Afghan National Police. The RCAC has the same function for the ANA corps and below.[18]

Afghan Police

References

  1. United Nations Security Council (28 September 2001), Resolution 1373
  2. Tommy Franks (2004), American Soldier, Harper Collins, ISBN 0060779543, pp. 270-272
  3. John C. K. Daly (May 4, 2007), "U.S. Air Base at Manas at Risk over Shooting Suspect?", Eurasia Daily Monitor, the Jamestown Foundation 4 (88)
  4. Franks, p. 264
  5. The United States Army in Afghanistan: Operation ENDURING FREEDOM (October 2001-March 2003), Office of the Chief of Military History, U.S. Army, p. 14
  6. Franks, pp. 301-305
  7. Gary Bertsen and Ralph Pezzulo (2005), JAWBREAKER: The attack on Bin Laden and al-Qaeda: A Personal Account by the CIA's Field Commander, Three Rivers Press, Crown Publishing Group, Random House, ISBN 0307351068, pp. 90-92
  8. Franks, p. 310-312
  9. "Operation Enduring Freedom - Operations", Globalsecurity
  10. Berntsen, pp. 145-146
  11. "Fight erupts, Taliban to surrender Konduz", United Press International, November 22, 2001
  12. Berntsen, p. 242
  13. Michelle Goldberg, "Were U.S. troops in Afghanistan complicit in a massacre?", Salon.com
  14. Luke Harding (November 27, 2001), "Allies direct the death rites of trapped Taliban fighters", Guardian (U.K.)
  15. 15.0 15.1 Robert Pelton (July 4, 2002), "Transcript of John Walker interview", CNN
  16. Berntsen, pp. 250-253
  17. Franks, p. 314
  18. CSTC-A Mission Fact Sheet on Afghanistan Regional Security Integration Command, ombined Security Transition Command - Afghanistan