Natrium reactor/Debate Guide: Difference between revisions
(add Elliot Negin's critique) |
(add intro) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ | {{subpages}} | ||
{{TOC|right}} | |||
Nuclear power is a controversial topic, and some of the controversies remain unsettled, even after the facts in the article are agreed on. This '''Debate Guide''' will provide a concise summary from each side of these unsettled issues. Much of this discussion is collected from Internet forums and other unreliable sources. We welcome updates with better sourcing. | |||
== Safety == | == Safety == | ||
'''Critique:''' by Elliot Negin (UCS), Commentary on Science in the News, Scientific American, Nov 2021, p.10<br> | '''Critique:''' by Elliot Negin (UCS), Commentary on Science in the News, Scientific American, Nov 2021, p.10<br> | ||
"Sodium coolant can burn when exposed to air or water, and the Natrium reactor could experience uncontrollable power surges that result in core melting."<br> | "Sodium coolant can burn when exposed to air or water, and the Natrium reactor could experience uncontrollable power surges that result in core melting."<br> | ||
'''Reply:''' | |||
==Waste Management== | |||
'''Critique:''' by Elliot Negin (UCS), Commentary on Science in the News, Scientific American, Nov 2021, p.10<br> | |||
"Natrium would likely be less uranium efficient and would not reduce the amount of waste that requires long-term isolation."<br> | |||
'''Reply:''' | '''Reply:''' | ||
Latest revision as of 20:35, 9 May 2023
Nuclear power is a controversial topic, and some of the controversies remain unsettled, even after the facts in the article are agreed on. This Debate Guide will provide a concise summary from each side of these unsettled issues. Much of this discussion is collected from Internet forums and other unreliable sources. We welcome updates with better sourcing.
Safety
Critique: by Elliot Negin (UCS), Commentary on Science in the News, Scientific American, Nov 2021, p.10
"Sodium coolant can burn when exposed to air or water, and the Natrium reactor could experience uncontrollable power surges that result in core melting."
Reply:
Waste Management
Critique: by Elliot Negin (UCS), Commentary on Science in the News, Scientific American, Nov 2021, p.10
"Natrium would likely be less uranium efficient and would not reduce the amount of waste that requires long-term isolation."
Reply: