Pashtun people: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Text replacement - "Northwest Frontier Province" to "North-West Frontier Province")
mNo edit summary
 
(7 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{subpages}}
{{subpages}}
{{TOC|left}}
{{Image|Flag of Pakhtunistan.png|right|350px|The Pashtun flag}}
{{Image|Flag of Pakhtunistan.png|right|350px|The Pashtun flag}}
'''Pashtuns''' (also known as Pakhtuns, Pathans) are an Eastern Iranian group primarily located in Southern [[Afghanistan]], and in the [[North-West Frontier Province]], [[Federally Administered Tribal Area]] and [[Balochistan]] of western [[Pakistan]]. The Pashtuns primarily speak the [[Pashto]] language, although a [[Dari]] speaking minority exists. [[Dari]], however, is the [[lingua franca]] of Afghanistan. Many Pathans of Balochistan speak [[Brahui]], a Dravidian language. Pathans settled in India mainly of the [[Lodi]] clan of the Ghilzai have throughout the centuries adopted the dominant language and Muslim customs practiced around them, although they continue to retain their Pathan identity. Pathan is the [[Hindustani language|Hindustani]] term for Pashtun.
'''Pashtuns''' (also known as Pakhtuns, Pathans) are an Eastern Iranian ethnic group primarily located in southern Afghanistan and in the [[Khyber Pakhtunkhwa]] and [[Balochistan]] provinces of western Pakistan. Pashtuns primarily speak the Pashto language, although there is a Dari-speaking minority. Dari is, however, the ''[[lingua franca]]'' of Afghanistan. Many Pashtuns of Balochistan speak Brahui, a Dravidian language. Pashtuns who settled in India were mainly of the Lodi clan of the Gilzai, and have throughout the centuries adopted the Muslim language and customs which were locally dominant, although they continue to retain their Pashtun identity.
 
Understanding Pashtun identity and governance is essential to understanding current relationships between Afghanistan and Pakistan, and indeed the [[Afghanistan War (2001-2021)]]. The [[Durand Line]], which forms the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan, follows physical but not political geography. It runs through areas of traditional Pashtun tribal governance.  A recent paper by a Pakistani infantry officer in residence at the U.S. [[Command and General Staff College]] observes  <blockquote>Like it or not, Afghanistan has always been a Pashtun country. Many as they are though, Uzbeks, Tajiks and Hazaras have always been the ‘outsiders’. Regardless of who holds the banner (the Taliban or anyone else) Pashtuns will never cease fighting unless given their leadership role in Kabul. They have always shed blood for the defense of their ‘right’ on the throne of Kabul. One can’t mess with that ‘right’ without incurring serious consequences. What we are facing in Afghanistan is ‘Pashtun Intifada’. It is only ‘led’ by bearded mullahs calling themselves ‘Taliban’. Take out Taliban and the insurgency will continue.<ref name=SWJ-Khan>{{citation
| url = http://smallwarsjournal.com/blog/journal/docs-temp/301-khan.pdf
| journal = [[Small Wars Journal]]
| title = Don’t Try to Arrest the Sea: An Alternative Approach for Afghanistan
| author = Mehar Omar Khan | date = October 2009}}</ref></blockquote> 


==History==
==History==
{{TOC|left}}
According to Vogelsang (2002), looking for the origin of the Afghans and Pashtuns is like "looking for the source of the Amazon river". It is unknown if there is a specific beginning, and whether the Pashtuns were originally identical with other Afghan ethnic groups.<ref>Vogelsang, Willem. ''The Afghans'', page 18. ISBN 0631198415</ref> Although their culture is different, Pashto is an Eastern Iranian language, and many Pashtuns speak Dari, a form of Persian generally associated with the Tajik language.


According to Vogelsang (2002), looking for the origin of the Afghans and Pashtuns is like looking for the source of the Amazon river. It's unknown if there's a specific beginning, and whether the Pashtuns were originally identical with other Afghan ethnic groups.<ref name=Volgelsang>Vogelsang, Willem - ''The Afghans'', page '''18''', ISBN 0631198415</ref> Although their culture is different, they do speak an [[Pashto|Eastern Iranian language]], and many Pashtuns speak [[Dari]], a form of Persian generally associated with [[Tajik language|Tajik]].
In his ''Histories'', [[Herodotus]] was the first writer to mention ethnic groups in what became Afghanistan, then known as Pakht or Pakhtria; and as Bactria in western literature. The term he used for the ethnic group was ''Pactyans''. Although it is not certain if this was the Pashtun ethnic group, there are similarities between ''Pakht'', ''Pakhtun'' (or ''Pukhtun''), and ''Pactyan''.


===In antiquity===
===Modern era===
In the late 1800s, the Durani king Abdur Rahman Khan initiated a resettlement program with two goals in mind, firstly, to move his Pashtun enemies as far away from Kabul as possible, and secondly, to break-up and displace the other major ethnic groups. Most Gilzais were thus relocated to the north of the Hindu Kush mountains, increasing tensions between the Gilzai and Durani.


[[Herodotus]] was the first to mention ethnic groups in modern Afghanistan, then known as ''Pakht'' or ''Pakhtria'', and ''[[Bactria]]'' in western literature. The term he used for the ethnic group is ''Pactyans''.<ref name=herodotus>Herodotus - ''Histories''</ref> Although it's not certain if this the Pashtun ethnic group, there are similarities between ''Pakht'', ''Pakhtun'' (or ''Pukhtun''), and ''Pactyan''.
The First (1839-42) and Second (1878-80) Anglo-Afghan Wars resulted in the Pashtun homeland being divided between Afghanistan and Pakistan (then part of British India), but the Durani kings subsequently refused to recognise Pashtun areas as part of Pakistan, creating tensions between the governments of Afghanistan and Pakistan.  


===Medieval era===
In the late twentieth century, the Marxist faction in the country was led by Nur Muhammed Taraki, a Gilzai, who organised a coup and overthrew the monarchy, which eventually led to the Soviet occupation. In the aftermath of the occupation, Pashtuns continued to dominate the government. During the occupation, tribal rivalries increased, and were influence by foreign factors. After the Soviet invasion, the Pakistani dictator General Zia-ul-Haq effectively prevented the Durani monarchs from having any role in the resistance, thereby preventing any re-establishment of the monarchy and giving rise to the Gilzai-based [[Taliban]]. Meanwhile, the tribal divide remained evident in the Afghan Communist Party, which split into Durani and Gilzai factions, both distrusting each other and working to undermine the other's power and influence.
 
===British empire era===
 
In the late 1800's, the Durrani King [[Abdur Rahman Khan]] initiated a resettlement program with two goals in mind, firstly, to move his Pashtun enemies as far away from [[Kabul]] as possible, and secondly, to break-up and displace the other major ethnic groups. Most Ghilzais were thus relocated to the north of the Hindu Kush mountains, increasing tensions between the Ghilzais and Durranis.
 
The[[First Anglo-Afghan War (1839-42)]] and [[Second Anglo-Afghan War (1878-80)]]  had resulted in the Pashtun homeland being divided between Afghanistan and Pakistan (then considered a part of [[British Raj|British India]]), and the Durrani Kings subsequently refused to recognise Pashtun areas as part of Pakistan, creating tensions between the governments of Afghanistan and Pakistan.
===Modern era===
In the late twentieth century, the Marxist faction in Afghanistan was led by [[Nur Muhammed Taraki]], a Ghilzai, who organised a coup and overthrew the monarchy, which eventually led to the [[Afghanistan War (1978-1992)|Soviet occupation]]. In the aftermath of the occupation, Pashtuns continued to dominate the government. During the occupation, tribal rivalries increased, and were influence by foreign factors. After the Soviet invasion, the Pakistani dictator General [[Zia Ul Haq]] effectively prevented the Duranni monarchs from having any role in the resistance, thereby preventing any re-establishment of the monarchy and giving rise to the Ghilzai-based [[Taliban]]. Meanwhile, the tribal divide remained evident in the [[Afghan Communist Party]], which split into Durrani and Ghilzai factions, with both factions distrusting each other and working to undermine the other faction's power and influence.
 
The Soviet withdrawal preceded the fall of the Communist government, which, in turn, led to a period of weak central government with power exerted by regional warlords. Part of the initial rise of the Pashtun-dominated [[Taliban]] was a response to the lawlessness, although the Taliban soon demonstrated their interpretation of Islam was more important than Pashtun tradition.


==Culture==
==Culture==
===Pashtunwali===
===Pashtunwali===
{{Image|Pashtun Elders.jpg|right|350px|Pashtun clan elders influence all the important decisions}}
Pashtunwali is the Pashtun code of conduct and honour, considered to be a combination of a Knight's [[chivalry]] and a Samurai's [[bushidō]]. It describes a Pashtun as a man of honour or ''ghairath'', and holds him to a certain standard in conducting his affairs, whether social, tribal, or national. The term "Pashtun" literally means ''man of honour''. Regardless of location, a Pashtun must adhere to the law of Pashtunwali, even with strangers, showing proper hospitality. Pashtunwali holds the guests to certain standards, to refrain from stretching his host's hospitality to the limits, and to avoid shameful acts. Manliness is a complex ideal in Pashtunwali. A Pashtun must protect anyone who seeks protection, even his enemies fleeing from their enemies. However, if a man has committed a shameful act, such as raping a woman, he then forfeits this right to protection, along with any other right to a Pashtun's hospitality. Elders play important roles in the clans and all important decisions are influenced by them.


Pashtunwali is the Pashtun code of conduct & honour, considered to be a combination of a Knight's [[chivalry]] and a Samurai's [[Bushido]]. It describes a Pashtun as a man of honour or ''ghairath'', and holds him to a certain standard in conducting his affairs, whether social, tribal, or national. The term "Pashtun" literally means ''man of honour''. Regardless of location, a Pashtun must adhere to the law of Pashtunwali, even with strangers, showing proper hospitality. Pashtunwali holds the guests to certain standards, to refrain from stretching his hosts hospitality to the limits, and to avoid shameful acts. Manliness is a complex ideal in Pashtunwali. A Pashtun must protect anyone who seeks protection, even his enemies fleeing from their enemies. However, if a man has committed a shameful act, such as raping a woman, he then forfeits this right to protection, along with any other right to a Pashtun's hospitality.
Pashtunwali guarantees the protection of the three ''Z''s ''Zan'' (woman), ''Zar'' (gold or property), and ''Zamin'' (land). These are the most important assets to a Pashtun, especially the women. Insulting, sexually harassing, or molesting a Pashtun woman can mean ruin for the culprit and his family, as it is the most un-Pashtun act a man can do. Violation of any of the three Zs can only be re-dressed by taking revenge (''badlaa''). A son can be killed for his father's crime, and ''vice-versa''. This way, a single crime or act can lead to family feuds that may last generations.<ref>Jones, Adam. ''Men of the Global South: A Reader'', page 368. ISBN 1842775138</ref> The phrase "revenge is a dish best served cold" is of Pashtun origin, borrowed by the British and popularised in the west.<ref>Halliday, Tony. ''Pakistan''. ISBN 9812585532</ref>
 
Pashtunwali guarantees the protection of the three ''Z'''s - ''Zan'' (woman), ''Zar'' (gold or property}, and ''Zamin'' (land). These are the most important assets to a Pashtun, especially the women. Insulting, sexually harassing, or molesting a Pashtun woman can mean ruin for the culprit and his family, as it's the most un-Pashtun act one can do. Violation of any of the three Z's can only be redressed by revenge taking (''badlaa''). A son can be killed for his father's crime, and vice-versa. This way, a single crime or act can lead to family feuds that may last generations.<ref name=Pashtunwali>Jones, Adams - ''Men of the Global South: A Reader'', page '''368''', ISBN 1842775138</ref> The phrase "Revenge is a dish best served cold" is of Pashtun origin, borrowed by the British and popularised in the west.<ref name=revenge>Halliday, Tony - ''Pakistan'', ISBN 9812585532</ref>
 
''[[Akarbai]]'' community police enforce the decision of tribal councils.
 
One argument made for the failure of the U.S. "Rewards for Justice" program in Afghanistan is pashtunwali. BBC reporter Frank Gardner explains, “Anyone caught betraying a fellow Muslim risks finding their family dishonored for generations.” He quotes CIA operations officer Mike Scheuer as to its relevance to [[Osama bin Laden]]:  “He’s been in Afghanistan since 9/11. It’s the third poorest place on the planet. We have $200 million of reward money outstanding, including $50 million for Osama and no one has come forward to take a cent. I think we need in the West to grow up a little bit. Everything doesn’t pivot on money.”<ref name=BBC2009-04-08>{{citation
| date = 8 April 2009
| url = US bounty scheme struggles in Pakistan
| author = Frank Gardner
| journal = BBC News
| url = http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7990538.stm}}</ref>


===Marriage===
===Marriage===
 
Most Pashtuns follow a type of hypergamy by which they arrange the marriage of their sisters and daughters to other Pashtuns. This is prevalent in Afghanistan, where most ethnic groups marry their womenfolk to within the ethnic group and above it, while the men marry within the ethnic group and below it. As the Pashtuns consider themselves the top ranked ethnic group, Pashtun women may marry only Pashtun men.<ref>[http://www.gl.iit.edu/govdocs/afghanistan/EthnicityAndTribe.html Afghanistan Country Study]. Paul V. Galvin Library, Illinois Institute of Technology.</ref>
Most Pashtuns follow a type of Hypergamy by which they arrange the marriage of their sisters and daughters to other Pashtuns. This is prevalent in Afghanistan, where most ethnic groups marry their womenfolk to within the ethnic group and above it, while the men marry within the ethnic group and below it. As the Pashtuns consider themselves the top ranked ethnic group, Pashtun women may marry only Pashtun men.<ref name=marriage>Paul V. Galvin Library, Illinois Institute of Technology - ''[http://www.gl.iit.edu/govdocs/afghanistan/EthnicityAndTribe.html Afghanistan Country Study]''</ref>


==Tribes and clans==
==Tribes and clans==
{{Image|Pashtun Tribes.png|center|600px|Pashtun tribal structure<ref>{{citation
The two main Pashtun tribes are the Gilzai and the Durani. Traditionally, the Durani have controlled Afghanistan's political affairs, although the Gilzai are the majority. In fact, Afghanistan's monarchy was founded by Ahmad Shah Durani in 1747. He had been a Persian general, but was elected at a ''loya jirga'' and also approved by the Muslim ''ulama''. He styled himself "Dur-i-Duran" (Pearl of Pearls) and his Pashtun Abdali tribe became known as the Durani. His family immediately lost the support of the tribes after his death in 1772, and control passed to the Mohammadzai lineage within the Barakzai section of the Durani Pashtun.<ref>{{citation |url=http://countrystudies.us/afghanistan/38.htm |editor=Peter R. Blood |title=Afghanistan: A Country Study |publisher=Library of Congress |year=2001 |contribution=Ethnic Groups}}</ref> The other important tribal groups are the Jaji, Mangal, Safi, Mamund, and Mohmand.
| author = Shahid Afsar,  [[Chris Samples]],  Thomas Wood
| journal = [[Military Review]], [[Command and General Staff College]]
| title = The Taliban: an Organizational Analysis
| date = May/June 2008
| url = http://www.humansecuritygateway.info/documents/MILREVIEW_Taliban_Organizational_Analysis.pdf}}</ref>}}


The two main tribes of the Afghans are the [[Ghilzai]] and the [[Durrani]]s. Traditionally, the Durranis have controlled Afghanistan's political affairs, although the Ghilzai are the majority. In fact, Afghanistan's monarchy was founded by [[Ahmad Shah Durrani]] in 1747. He had been a Persian general, but was elected at a [[loya jirga]] and also approved by the Muslim [[ulama]]. He styled himself "Durr-i-Durran" (Pearl of Pearls) and his  Pushtun Abdali tribe became known as the Durrani. When his immediate lost the support of the tribes after his death in 1772, control passed to the Mohammadzai lineage within the Barakzai section of the Durrani Pushtun.<ref name=LC-CS>{{citation
===Durani===
| url = http://countrystudies.us/afghanistan/38.htm
The Durani are dominated by two main clans, the Zirak and the Panjpia. The Zirak have historically been the elite, and the Afghan royal family came from the Mohamedzai sub-clan of the Ziraks. The Panjpia sub-clans include the Alizaj, Izhak, Koginaj, Maku, and Nurzai.<ref>Lansford, Tom. ''A Bitter Harvest: US Foreign Policy and Afghanistan'', pp. 16—17. ISBN 0754636151</ref>
| editor = Peter R. Blood
| title = Afghanistan: A Country Study
| publisher = Library of Congress | year = 2001
| contribution = Ethnic Groups}}</ref>


The other important tribal groups are the [[Jaji]], [[Mangal]], [[Safi]], [[Mamund]], and [[Mohmand]].
===Gilzai===
The Gilzai have been well known for their bravery and chivalry for many centuries. They are believed by most historians to be descended from Khilji Turks. Traditional historians are, however, of a different view. According to them, Ghilji and Lodi/Lodhi (Ibrahim Lodhi) were the offspring of Shah Hussain Ghauri by his first wife, Bibi Mato bint Bait Nikka bin Qais Abdul Rashid. The Gilzai may be the descendents of the Wu'chi (Indo-European/Turk) which absorbed the remnants of the Tocharian people (Indo-European) after the fall of the Tarim Basin to the Han Chinese. Important Gilzai clans include the Lodi, Suleiman Khel, Nasir Khel, Hotak, and Kharoti.


Elders play important roles in the clans and all important decisions are influenced by them.
==References==
{{Image|Pashtun Elders.jpg|left|350px|Pashtun clan elders influence all the important decisions}}
{{reflist|2}}
 
==Demography==


==Notes and References==
[[Category:Reviewed Passed]][[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]
{{reflist|2}}

Latest revision as of 16:01, 1 October 2024

This article is a stub and thus not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.
PD Image
The Pashtun flag

Pashtuns (also known as Pakhtuns, Pathans) are an Eastern Iranian ethnic group primarily located in southern Afghanistan and in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan provinces of western Pakistan. Pashtuns primarily speak the Pashto language, although there is a Dari-speaking minority. Dari is, however, the lingua franca of Afghanistan. Many Pashtuns of Balochistan speak Brahui, a Dravidian language. Pashtuns who settled in India were mainly of the Lodi clan of the Gilzai, and have throughout the centuries adopted the Muslim language and customs which were locally dominant, although they continue to retain their Pashtun identity.

History

According to Vogelsang (2002), looking for the origin of the Afghans and Pashtuns is like "looking for the source of the Amazon river". It is unknown if there is a specific beginning, and whether the Pashtuns were originally identical with other Afghan ethnic groups.[1] Although their culture is different, Pashto is an Eastern Iranian language, and many Pashtuns speak Dari, a form of Persian generally associated with the Tajik language.

In his Histories, Herodotus was the first writer to mention ethnic groups in what became Afghanistan, then known as Pakht or Pakhtria; and as Bactria in western literature. The term he used for the ethnic group was Pactyans. Although it is not certain if this was the Pashtun ethnic group, there are similarities between Pakht, Pakhtun (or Pukhtun), and Pactyan.

Modern era

In the late 1800s, the Durani king Abdur Rahman Khan initiated a resettlement program with two goals in mind, firstly, to move his Pashtun enemies as far away from Kabul as possible, and secondly, to break-up and displace the other major ethnic groups. Most Gilzais were thus relocated to the north of the Hindu Kush mountains, increasing tensions between the Gilzai and Durani.

The First (1839-42) and Second (1878-80) Anglo-Afghan Wars resulted in the Pashtun homeland being divided between Afghanistan and Pakistan (then part of British India), but the Durani kings subsequently refused to recognise Pashtun areas as part of Pakistan, creating tensions between the governments of Afghanistan and Pakistan.

In the late twentieth century, the Marxist faction in the country was led by Nur Muhammed Taraki, a Gilzai, who organised a coup and overthrew the monarchy, which eventually led to the Soviet occupation. In the aftermath of the occupation, Pashtuns continued to dominate the government. During the occupation, tribal rivalries increased, and were influence by foreign factors. After the Soviet invasion, the Pakistani dictator General Zia-ul-Haq effectively prevented the Durani monarchs from having any role in the resistance, thereby preventing any re-establishment of the monarchy and giving rise to the Gilzai-based Taliban. Meanwhile, the tribal divide remained evident in the Afghan Communist Party, which split into Durani and Gilzai factions, both distrusting each other and working to undermine the other's power and influence.

Culture

Pashtunwali

(CC) Photo: Keith Stanski
Pashtun clan elders influence all the important decisions

Pashtunwali is the Pashtun code of conduct and honour, considered to be a combination of a Knight's chivalry and a Samurai's bushidō. It describes a Pashtun as a man of honour or ghairath, and holds him to a certain standard in conducting his affairs, whether social, tribal, or national. The term "Pashtun" literally means man of honour. Regardless of location, a Pashtun must adhere to the law of Pashtunwali, even with strangers, showing proper hospitality. Pashtunwali holds the guests to certain standards, to refrain from stretching his host's hospitality to the limits, and to avoid shameful acts. Manliness is a complex ideal in Pashtunwali. A Pashtun must protect anyone who seeks protection, even his enemies fleeing from their enemies. However, if a man has committed a shameful act, such as raping a woman, he then forfeits this right to protection, along with any other right to a Pashtun's hospitality. Elders play important roles in the clans and all important decisions are influenced by them.

Pashtunwali guarantees the protection of the three Zs — Zan (woman), Zar (gold or property), and Zamin (land). These are the most important assets to a Pashtun, especially the women. Insulting, sexually harassing, or molesting a Pashtun woman can mean ruin for the culprit and his family, as it is the most un-Pashtun act a man can do. Violation of any of the three Zs can only be re-dressed by taking revenge (badlaa). A son can be killed for his father's crime, and vice-versa. This way, a single crime or act can lead to family feuds that may last generations.[2] The phrase "revenge is a dish best served cold" is of Pashtun origin, borrowed by the British and popularised in the west.[3]

Marriage

Most Pashtuns follow a type of hypergamy by which they arrange the marriage of their sisters and daughters to other Pashtuns. This is prevalent in Afghanistan, where most ethnic groups marry their womenfolk to within the ethnic group and above it, while the men marry within the ethnic group and below it. As the Pashtuns consider themselves the top ranked ethnic group, Pashtun women may marry only Pashtun men.[4]

Tribes and clans

The two main Pashtun tribes are the Gilzai and the Durani. Traditionally, the Durani have controlled Afghanistan's political affairs, although the Gilzai are the majority. In fact, Afghanistan's monarchy was founded by Ahmad Shah Durani in 1747. He had been a Persian general, but was elected at a loya jirga and also approved by the Muslim ulama. He styled himself "Dur-i-Duran" (Pearl of Pearls) and his Pashtun Abdali tribe became known as the Durani. His family immediately lost the support of the tribes after his death in 1772, and control passed to the Mohammadzai lineage within the Barakzai section of the Durani Pashtun.[5] The other important tribal groups are the Jaji, Mangal, Safi, Mamund, and Mohmand.

Durani

The Durani are dominated by two main clans, the Zirak and the Panjpia. The Zirak have historically been the elite, and the Afghan royal family came from the Mohamedzai sub-clan of the Ziraks. The Panjpia sub-clans include the Alizaj, Izhak, Koginaj, Maku, and Nurzai.[6]

Gilzai

The Gilzai have been well known for their bravery and chivalry for many centuries. They are believed by most historians to be descended from Khilji Turks. Traditional historians are, however, of a different view. According to them, Ghilji and Lodi/Lodhi (Ibrahim Lodhi) were the offspring of Shah Hussain Ghauri by his first wife, Bibi Mato bint Bait Nikka bin Qais Abdul Rashid. The Gilzai may be the descendents of the Wu'chi (Indo-European/Turk) which absorbed the remnants of the Tocharian people (Indo-European) after the fall of the Tarim Basin to the Han Chinese. Important Gilzai clans include the Lodi, Suleiman Khel, Nasir Khel, Hotak, and Kharoti.

References

  1. Vogelsang, Willem. The Afghans, page 18. ISBN 0631198415
  2. Jones, Adam. Men of the Global South: A Reader, page 368. ISBN 1842775138
  3. Halliday, Tony. Pakistan. ISBN 9812585532
  4. Afghanistan Country Study. Paul V. Galvin Library, Illinois Institute of Technology.
  5. Peter R. Blood, ed. (2001), Ethnic Groups, Afghanistan: A Country Study, Library of Congress
  6. Lansford, Tom. A Bitter Harvest: US Foreign Policy and Afghanistan, pp. 16—17. ISBN 0754636151