Larry Sanger: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Joe Quick
(Category:CZ Authors is for use on user pages (not on articles). This is more appropriate.)
imported>Aleksander Stos
(arguably, the three items are _not_ at the same logical level. First two are "local observables", the last is a "global explanation". So I adjusted numbering :))
Line 3: Line 3:
[[Nupedia]] was an encyclopedia that lasted from March of 2000 to September 2003.  Sanger was its salaried editor-in-chief until it ran out of funding in 2001 and Sanger resigned.  It was a Web-based effort that was supposed to be written and edited by experts in each field and although it was a [[free content]] encyclopedia it was not a [[wiki]] to which anyone with access to the Internet could contribute editorial content.  Although the project failed, it was a forerunner of Wikipedia, which was begun contemporaneously with Nupedia.
[[Nupedia]] was an encyclopedia that lasted from March of 2000 to September 2003.  Sanger was its salaried editor-in-chief until it ran out of funding in 2001 and Sanger resigned.  It was a Web-based effort that was supposed to be written and edited by experts in each field and although it was a [[free content]] encyclopedia it was not a [[wiki]] to which anyone with access to the Internet could contribute editorial content.  Although the project failed, it was a forerunner of Wikipedia, which was begun contemporaneously with Nupedia.


Co-founded by [[Jimmie Wales]] and Sanger, Wikipedia was a wiki-based project in which content could be contributed and edited anyone at all.  This time Sanger was characterized being as its salaried "chief organizer," although he had no official title.  Sanger stated later that "I stopped participating in Wikipedia when funding for my position ran out."<ref>http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2004/12/30/142458/25</ref>
Co-founded by [[Jimmie Wales]] and Sanger, Wikipedia was a wiki-based project in which content could be contributed and edited anyone at all.  This time Sanger was characterized being as its salaried "chief organizer," although he had no official title.  Sanger stated later that "I stopped participating in Wikipedia when funding for my position ran out."<ref>[http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2004/12/30/142458/25 Sanger's Kuro5hin essay]</ref>


In a well-known and controversial 31 December 2004 online essay at Kuro5hin<ref>all direct quotes cited here are from the same essay referenced above</ref> Sanger explained "Why Wikipedia Must Jettison Its Anti-Elitism" and detailed why "Wikipedia does have 2 big problems."   Sanger went on to expand upon Wikipedia's three (not two) main problems:
In a well-known and controversial 31 December 2004 online essay at Kuro5hin<ref>all direct quotes cited here are from the same essay referenced above</ref> Sanger explained "Why Wikipedia Must Jettison Its Anti-Elitism" and detailed why "Wikipedia does have 2 big problems." The problems he was referring to were
 
*"lack of public perception of credibility, particularly in areas of detail."
*"First problem: lack of public perception of credibility, particularly in areas of detail."
*"the dominance of difficult people, trolls, and their enablers."
*"Second problem: the dominance of difficult people, trolls, and their enablers."
As the root of these difficulties he identified "anti-elitism, or lack of respect for expertise."
*"The root problem: anti-elitism, or lack of respect for expertise."


Hoping to build upon his experience with the earlier encyclopedias and to avoid their pitfalls, Sanger launched Citizendium on 15 September 2006.  Originally conceived to be an improved [[fork]] of Wikipedia, it quickly evolved to its present form.  Its three main differences from Wikipedia are:
Hoping to build upon his experience with the earlier encyclopedias and to avoid their pitfalls, Sanger launched Citizendium on 15 September 2006.  Originally conceived to be an improved [[fork]] of Wikipedia, it quickly evolved to its present form.  Its three main differences from Wikipedia are:

Revision as of 09:36, 28 May 2007

Lawrence Mark ("Larry") Sanger (born 16 July 1968 in Bellevue, Washington) has been prominently associated with the intital projects of several online encyclopedias, the most notable being Wikipedia and Citizendium. Born in Washington but raised in Alaska, Sanger received a PH.D. in philosophy from Ohio State University in 2000.

Nupedia was an encyclopedia that lasted from March of 2000 to September 2003. Sanger was its salaried editor-in-chief until it ran out of funding in 2001 and Sanger resigned. It was a Web-based effort that was supposed to be written and edited by experts in each field and although it was a free content encyclopedia it was not a wiki to which anyone with access to the Internet could contribute editorial content. Although the project failed, it was a forerunner of Wikipedia, which was begun contemporaneously with Nupedia.

Co-founded by Jimmie Wales and Sanger, Wikipedia was a wiki-based project in which content could be contributed and edited anyone at all. This time Sanger was characterized being as its salaried "chief organizer," although he had no official title. Sanger stated later that "I stopped participating in Wikipedia when funding for my position ran out."[1]

In a well-known and controversial 31 December 2004 online essay at Kuro5hin[2] Sanger explained "Why Wikipedia Must Jettison Its Anti-Elitism" and detailed why "Wikipedia does have 2 big problems." The problems he was referring to were

  • "lack of public perception of credibility, particularly in areas of detail."
  • "the dominance of difficult people, trolls, and their enablers."

As the root of these difficulties he identified "anti-elitism, or lack of respect for expertise."

Hoping to build upon his experience with the earlier encyclopedias and to avoid their pitfalls, Sanger launched Citizendium on 15 September 2006. Originally conceived to be an improved fork of Wikipedia, it quickly evolved to its present form. Its three main differences from Wikipedia are:

  • that all contributors must apply for membership in the project under their real names, which are then visibly associated with all articles.
  • that all articles are reviewed by experts in that particular field who offer suggestions and criticism as the articles evolve, with the goal for each article to be "approved", meaning that it becomes mostly off-limits to further editing.
  • that vandals, trolls, and disruptive editors are quickly and permanently banned from further work on the project.

As of May, 2007, Sanger himself is an active contributor to several on-going articles in Citizendium.

References

  1. Sanger's Kuro5hin essay
  2. all direct quotes cited here are from the same essay referenced above