Free will: Difference between revisions
imported>John B. Mackenzie mNo edit summary |
imported>John B. Mackenzie mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
All of us subjectively experience being torn between doing one thing or another –what we would ''like'' to do, what we think we ''should'' do, or what we think others would appreciate our doing, and so on. We also assume that the decision is up to us, that we are free to do one thing or another, and others heap blame or praise on us assuming the same thing. This is what is meant | What do people mean when they say human beings differ from other animals because they have '''free will'''? All of us subjectively experience being torn between doing one thing or another –what we would ''like'' to do, what we think we ''should'' do, or what we think others would appreciate our doing, and so on. We also assume that the decision is up to us, that we are free to do one thing or another, and others heap blame or praise on us assuming the same thing. This is what is meant by ''free will'' –the belief that whatever we may have done in actual fact, we could always have decided on another course of action. | ||
At the same time, we realise that the world works in ways we can understand because there are law-like processes that we can decipher, and that allow us to explain what happens around us. The principle operating here is that events are [[caused]], not [[random]], a principle that is known as [[determinism]]. | At the same time, we realise that the world works in ways we can understand because there are law-like processes that we can decipher, and that allow us to explain what happens around us. The principle operating here is that events are [[caused]], not [[random]], a principle that is known as [[determinism]]. | ||
If the world is deterministic, that is it responds to patterns of [[cause]] and [[effect]], then human actions are either | If the world is deterministic, that is it responds to patterns of [[cause]] and [[effect]], then human actions are either an exception to this rule, or our feeling that we are free to decide what we like is simply an illusion. | ||
We have trouble | We have trouble believing all our actions are determined, and that our sense of freedom is totally illusory, but we also have problems thinking that our actions are totally outside the realm of causality. The latter position would make our actions random, and this is not a palatable idea for most of us... | ||
This is what in philosophy is known as the ''problem of free will'' | This is what in philosophy is known as the ''problem of free will'', and it is a problem because whichever road we choose to go down seems to lead us to conclusions that we would have trouble accepting. | ||
Revision as of 20:04, 18 October 2007
What do people mean when they say human beings differ from other animals because they have free will? All of us subjectively experience being torn between doing one thing or another –what we would like to do, what we think we should do, or what we think others would appreciate our doing, and so on. We also assume that the decision is up to us, that we are free to do one thing or another, and others heap blame or praise on us assuming the same thing. This is what is meant by free will –the belief that whatever we may have done in actual fact, we could always have decided on another course of action.
At the same time, we realise that the world works in ways we can understand because there are law-like processes that we can decipher, and that allow us to explain what happens around us. The principle operating here is that events are caused, not random, a principle that is known as determinism.
If the world is deterministic, that is it responds to patterns of cause and effect, then human actions are either an exception to this rule, or our feeling that we are free to decide what we like is simply an illusion.
We have trouble believing all our actions are determined, and that our sense of freedom is totally illusory, but we also have problems thinking that our actions are totally outside the realm of causality. The latter position would make our actions random, and this is not a palatable idea for most of us...
This is what in philosophy is known as the problem of free will, and it is a problem because whichever road we choose to go down seems to lead us to conclusions that we would have trouble accepting.