Talk:United Kingdom/Catalogs/Political subdivisions and dependencies

Article Checklist for "United Kingdom/Catalogs/Political subdivisions and dependencies"

Workgroup category or categories	Geography Workgroup, Politics Workgroup [Editors asked to check categories]
Article status	Developing article: beyond a stub, but incomplete
Underlinked article?	Yes
Basic cleanup done?	Yes
Checklist last edited by	Derek Harkness 01:38, 4 May 2007 (CDT)

To learn how to fill out this checklist, please see CZ:The Article Checklist.

---

Historical subdivisions

Perhaps this article should list the subdivisions of each of the four constituent kingdoms? This gets complicated - England is historically divided into counties; there are modern adminstrative counties plus London, which don't share the same borders, and there are the nine regions, which I think are clusters of the adminstrative counties. The historical counties have apparently never been abolished, so they should be listed, if only to preserve the glory that was Rutland. Anthony Argyriou 20:01, 4 May 2007 (CDT)

"Perhaps this article should list the subdivisions of each of the four constituent kingdoms?" - Using a tier system so that the articles mirror the structure of the country they are describing. This article breaks the UK down into one level of control below central government. Technically that's Scotland, Wales, 9 Regions and 6 counties since there is no England and (currently) no Northern Ireland as administrative subdivisions. But I'm willing to pretend England and NI exist for the moment.

I conceive of four more articles called something like Regions of England, Council Areas of Scotland, Counties of Wales and Counties of Northern Ireland where the second tier of government can be broken down and described. In Scotland, there's not much smaller than Council Areas, but in England you would break the 9 Regions down into Counties and other divisions as required.

"The historical counties have apparently never been abolished" - There is a difference between abolished and used and then used for what purpose? Many historical boundaries are only used ceremonially. I feel for the Gazetteer we should stick to present divisions. Another article could deal with historical divisions of England. Such a history article would be quite interesting, I could write the one for Scotland but not the English or Irish one. However, to mix the historical and the present together would probably only serve to confuse people who are not form the UK and don't understand our Country's structure.

I should also mention that I have listed this by Administrative divisions. The purpose is simply to make a Gazetteer that covers all of the UK. The a Gazetteer for the whole of England. It's not to list all the combinations of possible ways to split up the country, but rather to provide a tool to research the structure and geography of the country as it is now. There are other ways to divide the country that may justify their own articles such as UK parliament Constituencies or police division areas and so on.

I'd also like to start on a Gazetteer of Cities of the United Kingdom. Though, I don't think CZ is ready yet to go as deep as towns and villages (yet). - Derek Harkness 20:53, 4 May 2007 (CDT)

Guernsey

You might want to add about 1780 to your population figure for the Bailiwick of Guernsey since your island figure will exclude about 630 for Sark and about 1150 for Alderney. Wahib Frank 15:19, 12 May 2007 (CDT)

Done so, but you may want to check the figures and sources. The numbers I found are different form your numbers. I used the gov.gg sites, if you know a better source, then please point us to it. Derek Harkness 20:34, 12 May 2007 (CDT)

I know the figure for Sark via one of the Church wardens for St Peters Anglican church there - 600 or 620 is really here nor there. Alderney is more problematic for two reasons: there's a danger of including people twice since many people also have a residence in Guernsey, also because air access is available (unlike Sark) many tax exiles "pretend" to be on Alderney but are not really resident there in the usual meaning of the world. Since your articles deal with the official figures, I think they'll do nicely until you can update the Guernsey island figure.Wahib Frank 06:33, 13 May 2007 (CDT)

Dates of Union

The dates were recently altered and I disagree with the current dates for the following reasons.

Crown of Ireland Act 1542 didn't alter the ownership, or powers of the English King over Ireland. Nor did it mark a union of Ireland to England. Rather it changed the title of the King within Ireland. Since the 12th Century, Ireland had been subject to the rule of the English King (to varying degrees).

The date 927 for England implies that the other countries joined England in a biased relationship. Why list the date that England unified into one body but not list the date of Scotland unifying into a single Kingdom. Either we list when the individual countries formed themselves or when the counties ceased to be individual to form the United Kingdom. We should not do half of one and some of the other.

The Statute of Rhuddlan didn't mark a union either. This set down the laws for Wales. The union was enacted by Edward I and a big army several years prior to this Statute. As for the Statute of Rhuddlan, this was harmonising the fractured legal system within wales rather than to join Wales to England as the people of the time saw Wales as part of England. In the converse, one of the effects of the bill was to set in place the modern borders that mark the distinction between where Wales stops and England begins.

Aside from the personal unions of crowns and ignoring the wars of Independence in the 13th Century and the brief period under Cromwell's commonwealth I think there are only two dates that are significant of the UK article. The 1707 union that formed the United Kingdom and the 1801 union that added Ireland and possibly the 1921 date of Ireland dividing into North and South. The other histories can be dealt with in detail on the Scotland, England, Ireland and Wales pages as the UK