CZ:Objectivity Guidance: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Pat Palmer
mNo edit summary
imported>Pat Palmer
m (making link external)
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:


How might an ideal author write objectively?  Here are some suggestions:
How might an ideal author write objectively?  Here are some suggestions:
* '''Be factual'''.  A author would make immediate corrections to information found to be incorrect.
* '''Be factual'''.  A author would make immediate corrections to information found to be incorrect, and would not omit key facts to change how something seems.
* '''Avoid loaded language.'''  Loaded words are those that may influence an audience by using appeal to emotion or stereotypes. Name-calling is a classic example of loaded language.  
* '''Avoid loaded language.'''  Loaded words are those that may influence an audience by using appeal to emotion or stereotypes. Name-calling is a classic example of loaded language.  
* '''Use good sources.'''  The best sources are mainstream and reliable.  An author may sometimes accept non-mainstream sources for its references, if those sources are reasonably transparent and offer a publicly available mission statement and ownership information. Avoided would be sources without a transparent mission or known ownership, because such sources are commonly used for purveying intentional falsehoods, conspiracy, propaganda, extreme bias, and disinformation.  
* '''Use good sources.'''  The best sources are mainstream and reliable.  An author may sometimes accept non-mainstream sources for its references, if those sources are reasonably transparent and offer a publicly available mission statement and ownership information. Avoided would be sources without a transparent mission or known ownership, because such sources are commonly used for purveying intentional falsehoods, conspiracy, propaganda, extreme bias, and disinformation.  
Line 8: Line 8:
* '''Distinguish facts from opinion.''' I do not expect people to write as if they were an emotionless robot, never able to express an opinion.  The key to expressing opinions or emotions in knowledge writing is to admit what they are quite clearly and not try to pass them off as any one else's truth.  If you wish to include personal opinion in any of your writing here, please just own it; sign your name and the date using the <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> symbols.
* '''Distinguish facts from opinion.''' I do not expect people to write as if they were an emotionless robot, never able to express an opinion.  The key to expressing opinions or emotions in knowledge writing is to admit what they are quite clearly and not try to pass them off as any one else's truth.  If you wish to include personal opinion in any of your writing here, please just own it; sign your name and the date using the <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> symbols.


Nobody enjoys being manipulated or reading something that comes across as unfair.  Articles in ''The Citizendium'' are potentially subject to the same biases that occur in journalism.  Thus, I urge all our authors to become informed about the signs of potential biases and avoid them, both in their choice of words and in the sources for articles.  I offer as further guidance the detailed [https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/methodology/ assessment methodology of the Media Bias FactCheck website].
Articles in ''The Citizendium'' are potentially subject to the same biases that occur in journalism.  Thus, I urge all our authors to become informed about the signs of potential biases and avoid them, both in their choice of words and in the sources for articles.  I offer as further guidance the detailed <span class="newtab">[https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/methodology/ assessment methodology of the Media Bias FactCheck website]</span>.


[[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]], Citizendium domain-name owner. ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 21:56, 18 August 2020 (UTC)
[[User:Pat Palmer|Pat Palmer]], Citizendium domain-name owner. ([[User talk:Pat Palmer|talk]]) 21:56, 18 August 2020 (UTC)

Revision as of 07:01, 1 November 2021

The Citizendium welcomes contributions in all fields of knowledge. That said, the Citizendium management team prefers articles that are objective and remain free of advocacy, advertisement, and sensationalism.

How might an ideal author write objectively? Here are some suggestions:

  • Be factual. A author would make immediate corrections to information found to be incorrect, and would not omit key facts to change how something seems.
  • Avoid loaded language. Loaded words are those that may influence an audience by using appeal to emotion or stereotypes. Name-calling is a classic example of loaded language.
  • Use good sources. The best sources are mainstream and reliable. An author may sometimes accept non-mainstream sources for its references, if those sources are reasonably transparent and offer a publicly available mission statement and ownership information. Avoided would be sources without a transparent mission or known ownership, because such sources are commonly used for purveying intentional falsehoods, conspiracy, propaganda, extreme bias, and disinformation.
  • Not hiding dissent. Articles could try to represent dissention fairly, and not take sides. In cases where dissenters are a small proportion of all people involved, it is okay to mention that. In fact, not all dissent might make it into the main article but could be talked about on the Discussion page only.
  • Distinguish facts from opinion. I do not expect people to write as if they were an emotionless robot, never able to express an opinion. The key to expressing opinions or emotions in knowledge writing is to admit what they are quite clearly and not try to pass them off as any one else's truth. If you wish to include personal opinion in any of your writing here, please just own it; sign your name and the date using the ~~~~ symbols.

Articles in The Citizendium are potentially subject to the same biases that occur in journalism. Thus, I urge all our authors to become informed about the signs of potential biases and avoid them, both in their choice of words and in the sources for articles. I offer as further guidance the detailed assessment methodology of the Media Bias FactCheck website.

Pat Palmer, Citizendium domain-name owner. (talk) 21:56, 18 August 2020 (UTC)