Talk:Bobby Driscoll: Difference between revisions
imported>Joe Quick No edit summary |
imported>Oliver Renye m (re: Joe Quick) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Hi Oliver. Thanks for joining us at Citizendium. I had a look at the edit history for the Wikipedia version of this article. You must be user Bylot over there. | Hi Oliver. Thanks for joining us at Citizendium. I had a look at the edit history for the Wikipedia version of this article. You must be user Bylot over there. | ||
| Line 11: | Line 5: | ||
I haven't checked the other articles that you brought over at the same time, but the same criteria apply. Could you please either (1) remove the text that originated with other Wikipedia authors or (2) check the "from Wikipedia" box on the article and remove your notice above? Thanks much. | I haven't checked the other articles that you brought over at the same time, but the same criteria apply. Could you please either (1) remove the text that originated with other Wikipedia authors or (2) check the "from Wikipedia" box on the article and remove your notice above? Thanks much. | ||
--[[User:Joe Quick|Joe Quick]] 18:58, 22 November 2008 (UTC) | --[[User:Joe Quick|Joe Quick]] 18:58, 22 November 2008 (UTC) | ||
:Hello Joe, | |||
:Yes, at the Wikipedia I wrote (I don't write there anymore!) under the pseudonym Bylot. | |||
:When I started editing the former text on Bobby Driscoll in about March 2008 it was just a poor stub, and not very much is left now from the “original” text. | |||
:The articles on Billy Chapin and Sally Jane Bruce I also extended from brief stubs up to the today C- and start articles. | |||
:So in all three cases I consider myself the actual major author of them. | |||
:Yet I remove all three WPauthor templates. | |||
--[[User:Oliver Renye|Oliver Renye]] 19:35, 22 November 2008 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 14:35, 22 November 2008
Hi Oliver. Thanks for joining us at Citizendium. I had a look at the edit history for the Wikipedia version of this article. You must be user Bylot over there.
I noticed that there were a lot of other contributors to that article before you got involved, which means that some of the text you copied over here is not actually yours. That's okay, but we need to check the "from Wikipedia" box on the article. Your statement above is also somewhat misleading on that point. You say that you were the sole author of the text but that is not really true.
I haven't checked the other articles that you brought over at the same time, but the same criteria apply. Could you please either (1) remove the text that originated with other Wikipedia authors or (2) check the "from Wikipedia" box on the article and remove your notice above? Thanks much. --Joe Quick 18:58, 22 November 2008 (UTC)
- Hello Joe,
- Yes, at the Wikipedia I wrote (I don't write there anymore!) under the pseudonym Bylot.
- When I started editing the former text on Bobby Driscoll in about March 2008 it was just a poor stub, and not very much is left now from the “original” text.
- The articles on Billy Chapin and Sally Jane Bruce I also extended from brief stubs up to the today C- and start articles.
- So in all three cases I consider myself the actual major author of them.
- Yet I remove all three WPauthor templates.
--Oliver Renye 19:35, 22 November 2008 (UTC)