NOTICE: Citizendium is still being set up on its newer server, treat as a beta for now; please see here for more.
Citizendium - a community developing a quality comprehensive compendium of knowledge, online and free. Click here to join and contribute—free
CZ thanks our previous donors. Donate here. Treasurer's Financial Report -- Thanks to our content contributors. --

CZ:Moderator Group

From Citizendium, the Citizens' Compendium
(Redirected from CZ:Constabulary)
Jump to: navigation, search
Citizendium Moderator Group
Professionalism | Moderator Blocking Procedures | Article Deletion Policy
Application Review Procedure | Moderator Policy | Help for Moderators | Other
Home
Getting Started Organization Communication Technical Help Initiatives
Policies Editor Guidance Content Guidance Article Lists Governance
Welcome Page


Welcome to the Moderator Group!

Our Moderators are Citizendium's "community managers" They oversee adherence to basic policies, resolve behavioral — not editorial — disputes, and rein in troublemakers. Moderators also review applications and create new accounts, and can place the "approved" template into articles at the request of an Editor. They operate within a "separation of powers" and are held to a strict conflict of interest policy. For further information, see Moderator Policy.

The Moderator Charter Purview

Article 5

Citizens shall act responsibly and in a civil manner: derogatory or offensive language or behavior will not be tolerated. Citizens who interfere with another Citizen's rights as delineated by this Charter or who violate rules established by the Citizendium Council shall be subject to administrative action upon complaint of the aggrieved Citizen, the punishment of which may include, but is not limited to, suspension from the Citizendium for a period of time, or permanent expulsion. Other administrative actions may be established by the Citizendium Council.

Article 7

All Citizens shall be equal and no special privileges shall be granted except those granted in this charter to Editors and Officers.

Article 38

The Moderator Group shall enforce the Citizendium's rules of behavior as determined by the Citizendium Council, which shall apply equally to all Citizens regardless of status or position, including Editors and those with official positions. In particular, Moderators

  1. shall not intervene in matters of content, and
  2. shall act with reasonable pragmatism and leniency, and only in those situations where a behavioral dispute is clearly covered by existing rules.
  3. Moderators shall have power to block citizens' access to the Citizendium.
  4. Any act of the Moderators may be appealed to the Citizendium Council.

Some guiding conversations

From the Management Council (superseded by Citizendium Council)

When to call a Moderator

Authors should understand the relative domains of authority of Editors and Moderators: Editors handle disputes about content, while Moderators handle disputes about behavior. Moderators should not be asked to settle disputes that can be settled by a definitive answer to a content question; in that case, an Editor should be consulted. Moderators should be called when the dispute does not turn on a content question. For example:

  • An Author is straightforwardly ignoring decisions made by an Editor.
  • A contributor is acting abusively in the discussion page.
  • A contributor refuses to engage in any discussion about a disputed edit.
  • A contributor is very obviously ignoring project rules, for example, someone simply deletes without explanation all information about a view with which he disagrees.
  • Someone claiming to be an Editor is very obviously not entitled to do so, for example, because the user page has no, nonsensical, or irrelevant links to evidence of qualification.
Entry points

List of Constables

Daily Procedures

Solutions to Citizen Problems

How to:


Responses to behavior issues

{{nocomplaints}}
{{civil}}
{{inflammatory}}
{{Freshstart}}
{{acronym}}
  • Other useful templates
{{unsigned|User Name}}
{{UnsignedShort|User Name}}
{{NoRants}}



Citizendium Home

Governing Policy

Constabulary policy pages

Miscellaneous

A guide to Moderator procedures

Moderators, the following is the beginnings of a guide on how to do your job. Please help clarify and expand it as needed.


Responding to rude remarks, complaints, and flamebait placed on the wiki

Rude remarks shouldn't be tolerated; see Professionalism. If a paragraph of text contains personal attacks or other abusive language, Moderators should replace the whole paragraph (or a series of thus problematic paragraphs) with the {{civil}} template, which generates this message:

Text here was removed by the Constabulary on grounds of civility. (The author may replace this template with an edited version of the original remarks.)

Complaints by contributors about other contributors — authors, editors, and Moderators — should be made to the Moderator Group. Accordingly, such complaints are not permitted on the wiki. If a paragraph of text contains any such complaint, Moderators should replace the whole paragraph with the {{nocomplaints}} template, which generates this message:

A comment here was deleted by The Constabulary on grounds of making complaints about fellow Citizens. If you have a complaint about the behavior of another Citizen, e-mail constables@citizendium.org. It is contrary to Citizendium policy to air your complaints on the wiki. See also CZ:Professionalism.

Making repeated complaints about other users on the wiki can, after [how many?] warnings, lead to a user's at least temporary removal from the project. Abuse is dealt with much more strictly; see Moderator Blocking Procedures and We aren't Wikipedia.

Needlessly inflammatory remarks are to be deleted as well. The Moderator Group considers remarks needlessly inflammatory if any reasonable person should know that the remarks might provoke an acrimonious and unhelpful (e.g., off-topic) controversy--in other words, a pointless "flame war." Again, if a paragraph of text contains any such remarks, constables should replace the whole paragraph with the {{inflammatory}} template, which reads:

Text here was removed by the Constabulary on grounds that it is needlessly inflammatory. (The author may replace this template with an edited version of the original remarks.)

In general, but especially for minor issues, Moderators should engage people privately (aka off-wiki) when possible. If urgency is an issue, consider leaving a note on the user's talk page to inform them of your arriving email. To email any user, regardless of whether they have enabled "E-mail this user", go to that user's user page, then go to "Block user" (actually blocking requires a second step). Their email address will appear next to their name.

But which template to use?

  1. If a comment contains personal abuse, use {{civil}}.
  2. If a comment does not contain personal abuse, but contains complaints about another person, then use {{nocomplaints}}.
  3. If a comment contains neither abuse nor complaints, but is needlessly inflammatory, then use {{inflammatory}}.

In short, use exactly one of these templates as applicable in exactly this order: {{civil}}, {{nocomplaints}}, {{inflammatory}}.

Page deletion

To draft

For now, see Category:Speedy Deletion Requests and CZ:Article Deletion Policy.

Anti-vandalism procedures

See Anti-vandalism procedures.

The {{Approved}} template

See Approval Process with particular attention to this section.

All other Moderator templates

Constables, you can discuss creating new templates as the need arises.
Professionalism Policy
Neologisms/Acronyms
  • {{Acronym}}
    • Can be used with these switches:
      • |NPOV = "unbiased" or "neutral"
      • |OP = original poster
      • |OR = original research
      • |POV = "biased"
      • |BTW = by the way
Account creation


Where's my account password?

Passwords are generated and sent automatically, and then can 
be reset by you.  You should be able to go to

http://en.citizendium.org/wiki?title=Special:Userlogin&type=login

Enter your username and press "E-mail password."  In fact, 
I've just done that for you.  If you *didn't* receive this 
new password, check your spam/automatically deleted e-mail folder(s).

Once you get your new password, you should be able to log in. 
 Try editing your user page.  If you can't do that, it is 
probably because you need to confirm your e-mail address 
first.  (We have to have a working e-mail address on record.) 
 To do that, go to "my preferences" (at the top of every 
window on the wiki) and you should find a button that allows 
you to generate a mail that sends a new confirmation mail to 
your e-mail account.  Again, check any spam/automatically 
deleted e-mail folder(s) if you don't receive this.

Welcome aboard!

Other sysops on-wiki

People involved with development at Citizendium may have sysop powers but are not Moderators. Any sysop may use their powers to counter vandalism, however.